Monday, June 9, 2008

A PROVOCATIVE ARTICLE

Although I disagree with the mind-set and some of the assumptions of this author, Jennifer Roback Morse, this is a provocative article.

I have a strong hunch that her message is going to be taken quite seriously both in California and in the rest of the U.S., in that, once same-sex marriage is legalized, it is entirely conceivable that such man-made constructs as "civil unions" and "domestic partnerships" are going to lose their legal standing, such as it is, and I would not be all that unsympathetic to that turn of events.

I do believe that these arrangements are inferior to the dignity and legitimacy conferred by the designation of "marriage," and it is very likely, once marriage for same-sex couples is institutionalized in a given state and/or society as a whole, that civil unions and domestic partnerships will become void.

The following statement may increasingly gain traction among the populace and politicians: "Now that same sex couples can marry, there is no longer any excuse for the State of California to encourage non-marital cohabitation, by opposite sex couples or same sex couples. California should shut down the domestic partnership registries. Cohabitation is socially and privately inferior to marriage. The state should insist that couples either put up or shut up: get married or be single. No more half-way house of marriage-lite."

I urge you to read her article, located here.
Share |

2 comments:

DON CHARLES aka "STUFFED ANIMAL" said...

Good Lord, Jerry, this woman is a total crackpot. She's another student at the Ann Coulter School of Snide Journalism, and I sense she is no friend to LGBT folk. I browsed her blog and found her exchanging pleasantries with David Benkof. One of her posts endorsed his "defense" of "traditional" marriage. Provocation is useful when it's meant to make people think seriously about issues, but when it's done as Jennifer Morse does it (ideological provocation for its own sake), it's worthless. I'm glad I took the time to peruse her blog, though, because I found, in the form of a David Benkof comment, that he does NOT support LGBT parenting, though he implied otherwise in his infamous op-ed.

Jerry Maneker said...

Thanks Don Charles. Morse is dead set against same-sex marriage, and so is Benkof who, from what I've read of his, strikes me as a very conflicted human being. My point is that Morse's point may well gain traction once same-sex marriage is legalized, so that same-sex couples who choose not to get married may well not have the option of DP's or Civil Unions.